In this special Halloween episode, the group (with a special appearance by a previous guest) discuss:
- Halloween Riddles in a game of "Trick Or Treat"
- Candy Corn/Outdoor Parties/Non-Candy Treats/Out-Of-Season Horror Movies in "Our Beef"
- Heated Halloween debates in "Their Beef"
- "Questionable Beef": Who is the best "slasher"?